A recurring deposit and a SIP look identical on the surface — both are monthly auto-debits, both build wealth gradually. But over a 10+ year horizon, an equity SIP typically delivers 2-3× the after-tax maturity of an RD. The trade-off: equity volatility along the way. This calculator shows the real net-after-tax difference for your inputs.
Calculator → Comparison
Recurring DepositvsEquity SIP
Monthly into a bank fixed-rate vs into an equity mutual fund — same disciplined habit, very different outcomes.
Recurring Deposit Option A
Bank RD with fixed monthly contribution, fixed interest rate, taxed at slab. Capital fully protected.
Recurring Deposit (RD)
Equity SIP Option B
Monthly investment in equity mutual fund. Higher long-term returns, equity volatility, LTCG-taxed.
Equity SIP
The Verdict
–
Adjust the inputs above to see how the answer changes.
Get a personalised comparison report
Drop your email and we’ll send a custom PDF summary tailored to your inputs above — plus weekly tips on investing, taxes, and business finance.
No spam, unsubscribe anytime. We never share your email.Ready to turn knowledge into wealth?
Master investing, business finance & accounting with our structured, expert-led courses.
Why the Gap Is So Big
- Higher gross return: SIPs return 11-13% long-term; RDs typically 5.5-7%.
- Tax efficiency: Equity LTCG is 12.5% over ₹1.25L; RD interest is taxed at slab (often 30% for high earners).
- Compounding effect: A 5%+ return-rate gap over 15-25 years compounds to multiples, not just percentages.
When RD Is the Right Choice
- Goal < 3 years away — equity volatility is too risky for short horizons.
- Emergency fund building — you need certainty, not maximum returns.
- Senior citizens — RDs and FDs offer additional 0.5% interest + ₹50K tax exemption u/s 80TTB (India).
- Risk-averse first-time savers — building habit matters more than maximising returns initially. Once you’re comfortable, switch to SIP.
Why SIP Wins Over Long Horizons
- Outpaces inflation comfortably — equity returns are well above 5-6% inflation; RD often barely beats it after tax.
- Power of compounding on higher rate — small per-year differences compound to multiples over 15-30 years.
- Cost-averaging benefit — SIPs buy more units in market dips automatically.
- No reinvestment risk — you don’t face declining interest rates the way RD/FD savers do.
Hybrid Strategy (Most Recommended)
Don’t pick one — use both based on goal horizon:
- Emergency fund (3-6 months expenses) — bank account / liquid mutual fund / RD
- 0-3 year goals — RD or short-duration debt mutual fund
- 3-7 year goals — hybrid funds (60% equity / 40% debt)
- 7+ year goals (retirement, education) — equity SIP
Frequently Asked Questions
Is RD interest taxable?▾
Can RD return drop during the period?▾
Should beginners start with RD or SIP?▾
What about hybrid mutual funds?▾
Ready to turn knowledge into wealth?
Master investing, business finance & accounting with our structured, expert-led courses.
